Stern, Steve J. Reckoning with Pinochet: The Memory Question in Democratic Chile, 1989-2006. Durham: Duke University Press, 2010. 548 pages; 30 illustrations; $99.95 cloth, $27.95 paper.
Chapter One covers the political and legal endgame of the military regime, the restoration of democracy, the confrontation with the dangers of truth, and the exceedingly delicate work of the National Truth and Reconciliation Commission (also known as the Rettig Commission). Chapter Two features an in-depth analysis of the Commission’s focus on documenting indisputable cases of death caused by state agents as a foundation for future legal action, and the attendant political and memory fallout from this narrow scope of attention. The third and fourth chapters largely cover the reforms carried out on the Chilean court system and military, along with the memory impasses that occurred, the continuing efforts to break through them, and also the unintentional ruptures caused by what Stern refers to as “memory knots.” These are places and times charged with meaning and tend toward the disruption of complacency and exhaustion. Stern’s memory knots are notably similar to what theorist Nelly Richard has called “cultural residues.” Other theorists, such as Idelber Avelar and Willy Thayer, have discussed the phenomenon at length as well, although this critical conversation is conspicuously absent from the trilogy. Chapter Five revisits the pivotal events of 1998 and the arrest of Pinochet in London, which are discussed in much greater detail within the first book of the trilogy, Remembering Pinochet’s Chile (2004). The final two chapters of the book describe the new national situation that followed, and of particular interest are the sections (in these chapters and previous ones) on the work of Judge Juan Guzmán Tapia, who was a leading force in the prosecution of Chilean human rights abuses until his retirement in 2005. Another vital event discussed at length is the work of the Velich Commission, whose November 2004 report finally confronted the issue of torture during the dictatorship, which the Truth and Reconciliation Commission had intentionally left aside, to the consternation of many.
Much of the historical and cultural criticism on the post-dictatorship focuses on two diametrically opposed memory camps, and the official efforts to arrive at a much-maligned “consensus,” which serves as a sort of false consciousness by which the deep conflicts inherent in Chilean society are in effect papered over, but still bubbling under the surface. Stern’s approach, on the other hand, is not so plainly dialectical, and allows for a distinct representation of the dynamics driving sociopolitical change during the fluid early years of political transition and the later democratic and institutional stabilization that followed. Stern portrays the middle space between the two camps, occupied by the political elite of the left-leaning Concertación de Partidos por la Democracia and the more right-leaning parties, to have been a powerful source of memory narrative and democratic action that acted independently and often in necessary realpolitik compromise with the country’s military and business sectors, while asserting the authority and legitimacy of the new government. Stern’s thesis, however, shows the way in which tensions between truth, justice, and memory caused tectonic shifts in the politico-cultural environment and the eventual emergence of a new memory script of “shared tragedy,” even for the military and the technocratic right, even as the “war thesis” persists in certain circles. Far from serving as an apologist for the Chilean political class, Stern attempts to relate the shortcomings, successes, and mitigating factors in the long struggle toward rebuilding a shattered nation.
Stern’s now-completed trilogy is a remarkably varied, multi-disciplinary, and well-researched study of the Chilean memory question and recent history in general. It provides a number of insightful frameworks to describe the relationships between history, memory, and politics in the process of democratic reconstruction. By virtue of its clear explanations and graceful prose, it is well-suited for any readers interested in Chile or general issues of human rights and memory studies. It lays the foundation for more work in cultural and literary studies, and will surely remain one of the most important works in the field for years to come.
Patrick Blaine completed his PhD in Comparative Literature at the University of Washington. He is currently an Assistant Professor of Spanish at Morningside College in Sioux City, Iowa, teaching language, literature, cinema, and cultural studies. His work explores comparative aspects of literary and film studies in the post-dictatorial Southern Cone, and Latin America in general.
Memories of Reconciliation: Photography and Memory in Postwar Peru
Deborah Poole and Isaías Rojas Pérez
Politics of Representation. Art & Human Rights
Andrea Giunta
Traumatizing the Truth Commission:Amnesty, Intentionalist Teleology, and the Event
Allen Feldman
The Power of Pink: Performing the Archive in the Works of Ernesto Salmerón
Carla Macchiavello
¿Y, después de la verdad? El espacio público y las luchas por la memoria en la post CVR, Perú
María Eugenia Ulfe and Cynthia Milton
Trauma, memoria y performance: Un recorrido por Villa Grimaldi con Pedro Matta
Diana Taylor
Means and End/s of Clandestine Life
Diane Nelson
Depths of the Present: State Violence and the Neoliberal State
Clara Han
The Nation Gathers
Naomi Angel
El tumulto de las fronteras
Nelly Richard
¿Espacios para la memoria? ¿Para quiénes?
Elizabeth Jelin
Ni más ni menos. Los mismos derechos, con los mismos nombres: 2010, año de la igualdad en Argentina
Esteban Paulón
Chile’s MarchaRearme and the Politics of Counter-Commemoration
Katherine Hite
Apuntes fotográficos de posdictadura
Natalia Fortuny
Mozambique: Reconciliation without "Truth"
Juan Obarrio
Still Waiting
Jo-Marie Burt
Seeing, Counting, Taking Time: Memory and the Iraq War
Marita Sturken
la geometría de la conciencia
Alfredo Jaar
Against the Grain: Cultural Politics After Peru's Troubled Times
Macarena Gómez-Barris
Marina Abramović’s Time: The Artist is Present at the Museum of Modern Art
Abigail Levine
Contextualizing Truth: Recent Contributions to Discourses of Reconciliation in Canada
Naomi Angel
Desmemoria y Perversión: privatizar lo público, mediatizar lo íntimo, administrar lo privado by Fernando A. Blanco
Isabel Baboun Garib
Reckoning with Pinochet: The Memory Question in Democratic Chile, 1989-2006 by Steve J. Stern
Patrick Blaine
Trans Desire by Micha Cárdenas
Zach Blas
El siluetazo, edited by Ana Longoni and Gustavo Bruzzone
Celina Fassi Cardoso
Crítica de la memoria: 1990-2010 by Nelly Richard
Jean Franco
On Art, Artists, Latin America, and Other Utopias by Luis Camnitzer
Antonia Garcia Orozco
Performing South Africa’s Truth Commission: Stages of Transition by Catherine M. Cole
Robyn Green
The President Electric: Ronald Reagan and the Politics of Performance by Timothy Raphael
Angela Marino Segura
Where memory dwells: Culture and state Violence in Chile by Macarena Gómez-Barris
Kaitlin McNally-Murphy
Prismas de la memoria: narración y trauma en la transición chilena by Michael J. Lazzara
Judith Sierra-Rivera
Telling Ruins in Latin America, edited by Michael J. Lazzara and Vicky Unruh
Tamara Lea Spira
Memoria en construcción: el debate sobre la Esma, edited by Marcelo Brodsky
Yael Zaliasnik Schilkrut
¿Patria o muerte? by Pablo Ramírez
Reinaldo Amién Gutiérrez
Halcón de Oro Qorihuaman by Rodolfo Rodríguez and Raúl Cisneros
Ivone Barriga
The smell of Popcorn by Teatro iati and World Players, Inc.
Li Cornfeld
Cimientos Performance Workshop and Symposium
Tara Daly
Blackwaters by Matthew B. Jenkins
Adriana Pilar Nieto
Solo with Variations 2 (For Vladimir Ilich L.) by Nelson Rivera / Mizery
Lilliana Ramos Collado
Fernando Pertuz
Miguel Rojas-Sotelo
Situación de Colombia by Teatro Efímero Putumayo
Paloma Salgado Jiménez
Mi vida después
Cecilia Sosa
Vidas paralelas
Cynthia E. Milton
Felandus Thames
Charlie Samuya Veric