McCaughan, Edward J. Art and Social Movements: Cultural Politics in Mexico and Aztlán. Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2012. 232 pages; $23.95 paper.
Art and Social Movements returns to themes of social movements, state-society relations, political identities, and gender and sexuality, which have long found expression in sociologist Edward J. McCaughan’s books and articles. The new book’s particular emphasis on activist art, however, extends specifically McCaughan’s more recent research on the role of artists and art in Mexican and Chicano social movements (e.g. McCaughan 2002). Across six chapters, McCaughan weaves together his insights from engagement with artists working alongside Mexico City’s 1968 student movement, the Chicano civil rights movement of the 1960s and ’70s, and the Coalición Obrera-Campesina-Estudiantil del Istmo of Oaxaca in the 1970s and ’80s. The event of 1968 is treated as a “watershed” that definitively changed the “cultural-ideological realities” of which these movement constellations are a part (Wallerstein 1989, 431). Also looming large in McCaughan’s account is the post-revolutionary Partido Revolucionario Institucional (PRI)-controlled state and its “mode of regulation,” in which a nationalist regime of representation and a unifying historical narrative centered on Mexico City are included.
McCaughan argues that art associated with social movements not only reflects but constitutes the political and social change that those movements have been seen to effect. In the process, McCaughan makes novel theoretical contributions to theories of so-called new social movements, while at the same time consolidating conceptual advances of more established, if now frequently neglected, theoretical frameworks such as regulation theory. This is particularly evident in the book’s nuanced synthesis of attention to cultural politics and to political economy. For McCaughan, a focus on art need not result in a sacrifice of concern for specificities of regional contexts. Indeed, “the political importance of visual discourses produced by movement artists only becomes apparent when read against prevailing social structures, regimes of accumulation, and systems of representation” (3).
The book’s treatment of the regional contexts against which visual discourses are read demands further consideration. In this regard, it must be noted that, even given the traditional social-scientific methods through which McCaughan’s analysis proceeds (i.e. interviews, archival research, and attendance of relevant events), the book appears as a model of postempiricist scholarship. McCaughan does slip into empiricism—when, for example, he delineates the absolute spaces Oaxaca, Mexico City, and California as his sites of research. But the relevant elements of the regional contexts against which McCaughan reads activist art are not “out there” to be examined and reported upon, and “there” is clearly not a point that can “be understood by appeal to what exists only at that point” (Harvey 2006, 274). Rather, these contexts come together around McCaughan, who appears as a product of his inheritances. McCaughan’s writing is solicited by writings and visual artworks, and by the triumphs and tragedies of the activists and artists with whom he has evidently developed deep connections (cf. Ismail 2005). In this sense, the regions invoked in the book’s title—Mexico and Aztlán—are simultaneously object and subject in relation to which McCaughan seeks an opening for what Alberto Moreiras (2001, 164-5) would perhaps identify as heretofore “unrepresentable positivities.”
If McCaughan productively disturbs the geographical foundations of movement constellations, he also mounts a challenge to historical discourses and prominent pre- and post-68 representations of the Mexican Left. Chapters two and three notably show how—amidst a fraying of the “revolutionary family” (Zolov 1999)—artists created visual discourses that facilitated the enactment of new modes of citizenship, themselves rendered fragile by unresolved exclusions along lines of race, class, gender, and sexuality. For example, while post-1968 representations of the student-Left by activist artists rejected the nationalist iconography of “Mexican School” social realism, the emerging regime of representation was not unproblematic. In representations concurrent with the 1968 student movement, and particularly after the October 2 massacre in Tlatelolco, there emerged a heterosexist discourse of revolutionary nationalism largely compatible with the visual language of the PRI regime. The book’s evidence of the historical narratives and artistic representations that worked to restrain the agency of homosexuals and women suggests the PRI’s post-Tlatelolco cover-up spawned a second erasure, this time enacted under the banner of “heroic” student activism defined starkly against the “repressive” Mexican state. McCaughan’s analysis of the three movement constellations indicates that such a process of erasure was not exclusive to the ’68 student movement (cf. chapter five), and his critique complements interventions by contemporary artists to seek a way through this bind.
McCaughan sets out and delivers on grand ambitions. Addressing the relationship between artistic practices and activism in Mexico and Aztlán after 1968, the scope of his project is enormous. Choices had to be made for the short book (barely eclipsing 200 pages,) and—as a result—McCaughan did neglect some significant contemporary artists whose work could have enhanced his account. But, if not exhaustive, every discussion opens directions for further research. Much can also be said for the evident care taken in the book’s writing and editing stages. The text is gracefully written; the index and bibliography serve as useful guides to the book and its sources; and the images are well reproduced in black and white. Finally, Art and Social Movements reflects political commitment; McCaughan takes positions, and does not simply report on past activism and activist art. Despite McCaughan’s disclaimer that “[his] passion for art may tip the balance,” (xvi) what emerges from his research is a de-romanticized vision of Mexican artists and activists which productively discourages historiographic and political closure. Amidst an apparent resurgence of the PRI regime, and young activists’ insistent commemoration of the Tlatelolco Massacre to which so many post-68 artists felt called upon to respond (such as in ongoing agitation under the sign of #YoSoy132, and in the wake of repression at the escuelas normales earlier this year,) McCaughan’s critical engagement with inherited narratives is timely.
Nicholas Jon Crane is a Ph.D. Candidate in the Department of Geography at The Ohio State University. Crane’s writing has been published in Human Geography,Reviews in Cultural Theory, Fifth Estate, The Geographical Bulletin, and other venues. He also has publications forthcoming in Cultural Studies ó Critical Methodologies, and ACME: An International E-Journal for Critical Geographies. Crane works at the intersections of Political, Historical, and Cultural Geography, Cultural Studies, and Political Theory. He is currently writing his dissertation on memory, the state, and young people’s politics in the wake of Tlatelolco/1968 in Mexico City.
Works cited:
Harvey, David. 2006. Spaces of Global Capitalism: Towards a Theory of Uneven Geographical Development. New York: Verso.
Ismail, Qadri. 2005. Abiding by Sri Lanka: On Peace, Place, and Postcoloniality. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
McCaughan, Edward J. 2002. “Gender, Sexuality, and Nation in the Art of Mexican Social Movements.” Nepantla: Views from South 3, no. 1: 99-143.
Moreiras, Alberto. 2001. The Exhaustion of Difference: The Politics of Latin American Cultural Studies. Durham: Duke University Press.
Wallerstein, Immanuel. 1989. “1968, Revolution in the world-system.” Theory and Society 18, no. 4: 431-449.
Zolov, Eric. 1999. Refried Elvis: The Rise of the Mexican Counterculture. Berkeley: University of California Press.
tendencias Humanas
Ed Cohen
APARENCIAS E MODOS DE VIDA: TOPOGRAFIAS DO VIVIENTE NA POESIA E NAS ARTES VISUAIS
Eduardo Jorge
fronteiraS Do humano
María Esther Maciel
Espacios de Especies
Raúl Antelo
Para Una Teoría Literaria Posthumanista
Julieta Yelin
Comunidad, Inmunidad, Biopolítica
Roberto Esposito
Animals and Archives
Zeb Tortorici
Eduardo Viveiros de Castro: Some Reflections on the Notion of Species
Álvaro Fernández Bravo
El Animal Comunista
Gabriel Giorgi
Performing Biotechnology
Jennifer Willet
una especie no endemica: o bicho suspenso na paisagem de ernesto neto
Álvaro Fernández Bravo
AKBAR STOLE MY HEART: COMING OUT AS AN ANIMALIST
Alexandra Isfahani- Hammond
El Matadero
Martín Kohan
KILTR@
Cheto Castellano and Lissette Olivares
LA VOZ PRESTADA DE LOS ANIMALES
Sergio Chejfec
Sobre biopolítica y el Giro Animal: entrevista con cary wolfe
Cary Wolfe and Gabriel Giorgi
Sentencia de Vida
Fermín Rodríguez
Species and belonging
Nuno Ramos
pintacanes
Lissette Olivares
May the horse live in me
Marion Laval-Jeantet
performing the u.s. latina and latino borderlands por Arturo j. Aldama, chela sandoval, and peter j. garcia
Yvette Martinez-Vu
From Liberation to Conquest: the Visual and Popular Cultures of the Spanish-American War of 1898 por Bonnie M. Miller
Autumn Womack
animacies: biopolitics, racial mattering, and queer affect por Mel y. chen
Leon Hilton
Neoliberalism and Global Theatres: Performance and Permutations Editado por Lara D. Nielsen and Patricia Ybarra
Camila González Ortíz
How a revolutionary art became official culture: murals, museums, and the mexican state por mary coffey
Christopher Fraga
Raíces y semillas: maestros y caminos del teatro en América Latina por miguel rubio zapata
Carla Pereira Souza
Art and Social Movements: Cultural Politics in Mexico and Aztlán por Edward J. McCaughan
Nicholas Crane
God's Laboratory: Assisted Reproduction in the Andes por Elizabeth F.S. Roberts
Angela Castañeda
Becoming Undone: Darwinian Reflections on Life, Politics and Art por Elizabeth Grosz
Juan Marguch
Exercises for Rebel Artists: Radical Performance Pedagogy por Guillermo Gomez-Pena and Roberto Sifuentes
Antonio Prieto Stambaugh
Jungle Fever: Exploring Madness and Medicine in Twentieth Century Tropical Narratives por Charlotte Rogers
Felipe Martínez Pinzón
Viajes Virales por Lina Meruane
Sebastián Reyes
before the law: humans and other animals in a biopolitical frame por cary wolfe
Gabriel Giorgi
The spirits and the law: Vodou and Power in Haiti por Kate Ramsey
Gina Athena Ulysse
Every Twelve Seconds: Industrialized Slaughter and the Politics of Sight por Timothy Pachirat
Susan Grelock
The National Dance Theatre Company of Jamaica's 50th anniversary season
Lara Cahill-Booth
La Aguja, una pelícla de Carmen Oquendo-Villar y Jose Correa-Vigier
Liliana Ramos Collado